Sustainability at Eurobank is deployed across an ESG governance structure that addresses both regulatory requirements and voluntary commitments. BoD oversight with respect to ESG Strategy is addressed through the inclusion of ESG items in the Board Meetings agenda, as per international best practice.
The Group has updated its governance structure by introducing and defining the roles and responsibilities in relation to ESG and climate related and environmental risks, embedding regulatory guidelines and market practices.
The Group applies the elements of the three lines of defence (3LoD) model for the management of operational risk overall. The three lines of defence model enhances risk management and control by clarifying roles and responsibilities within the organisation.
Eurobank’s ESG governance model also ensures that the management of relevant climate-related and environmental risks is integrated in the Bank’s three lines of defence.
The updated governance structure aims to further enhance the effective oversight of ESG matters at Management / BoD level.
Over the past year, the Bank has taken significant steps to enhance its ESG governance model, and support the roll out of its ESG strategy and the integration of ESG and C&E risks.
Enhanced Governance Structure and Committees
- Oversight of climate risks at management body level through allocation of responsibilities to BoD and management committees.
- A BoD Member is responsible for climate-related and environmental risks.
- Establishment of two Committees that supplement the governance arrangements in the area of ESG / climate risk i.e. Environmental, Social & Governance Management Committee and Climate Risk Stress Test Committee.
Integration of CR&E Risk Management across the three lines of defence
- Dedicated teams within CIB and Retail Divisions, for overseeing ESG and sustainable financing activities.
- Automated process established to assess and classify sustainable opportunities.
- ESG Division responsible for the design and monitoring of the Operational Impact Strategy and oversight of the Bank’s overall ESG performance.
- Group Climate Risk Division responsible for managing and monitoring CR&E risks, PMO office for the implementation of the Climate Related and Environmental risks roadmap, preparation and submission for approval of the Financed Impact Strategy, along with Business and Risk Units.
- Intensive training on sustainable finance and climate risk to Bank personnel.
The roles and responsibilities of the key governance bodies / committees / divisions are as follows:
Board of Directors (BoD / Board)
Operates guided by Group’s vision, values and standards; sets the strategic aims of the Group, assesses the potential risks and manages them sensibly and efficiently; ensures that robust processes are in place to monitor organisational compliance with the agreed strategy and risk appetite and with all applicable laws and regulations. The Eurobank Holdings / Eurobank Boards have assigned an executive member as the BoD Member responsible for CR&E risks. As part of his duties the responsible BoD member updates the BoDs of the Eurobank Holdings and of the Bank on climate change and environmental related risks at least on a semi-annual basis.
Board Risk Committee (BRC)
Oversees implementation of and adherence to the Bank’s risk policies, including climate-related and environmental risks, in order to assess their adequacy against the approved risk appetite and strategy; determines the principles which govern climate-related and environmental risk management across the Bank and the Group in terms of identifying, measuring, monitoring, controlling and mitigating risks; approves risk principles, risk policies, procedures and methodologies. Additionally, the Group has established two Committees that supplement the governance arrangements in the area of ESG/Climate risk.
Management Risk Committee (MRC)
Oversees the risk management framework of the Group. As part of its responsibilities, the MRC facilitates reporting to the BRC on the range of risk-related topics under its purview, including CR&E risks. The MRC ensures that material risks are identified and promptly escalated to the BRC and that the necessary policies and procedures are in place to prudently manage risk and to comply with regulatory requirements.
Environmental, Social & Governance Management Committee (ESG ManCo)
Provides strategic direction on ESG initiatives; reviews the ESG Strategy prior to approval; ensures the integration of the elements of the ESG Strategy into the Bank’s business model and operations; regularly measures and analyses the progress of the ESG goals and performance targets; ensures the proper implementation of ESG-related policies and procedures, reviews and approves ESG-related reports and ensures that they are in accordance with related Standards and Guidelines. It is chaired by the BoD Member responsible for climate-related and environmental risks.
Climate Risk Stress Test Committee (CRSTC)
Is responsible for designing and executing the Group’s CRST Programme; coordinates all activities relating to Climate Risk Stress Testing including risk identification, scenario design and stress test execution; reviews and challenges the output at each stage of the process prior to escalating to the Executive Board.
Going forward, the Bank aims to enhance the CR&E risk oversight responsibilities for the management body by introducing climate risk related aspects in the Bank’s fit and proper criteria, considering relevant ECB consultation. Additionally, the Bank plans to provide dedicated training on CR&E risks to the management body members and to further update the Terms of Reference (ToRs) of Board and Management Committees to incorporate and allocate additional responsibilities for the oversight of the CR&E risks.
ESG Division
The ESG Division acts as a custodian of ESG Principles and Culture to enhance the Bank’s Impact, and as a cross functional coordinator to ensure alignment on ESG issues and interdependencies, as well as compliance with relevant existing and upcoming operational impact related regulations. Specifically, the ESG Division is responsible for designing / reviewing the ESG Operational Impact Strategy and monitoring its implementation, with a leading role in selected areas, providing also support to international subsidiaries. Furthermore, the ESG Division coordinates and prepares ESG operational impact-related reports in line with applicable standards/ regulations, in cooperation with involved subject-matter responsible Units, while it is responsible for the UNEP FI PRB implementation. Being responsible for the oversight of the Bank’s overall ESG operational performance, its key roles include the centralised management of ESG Ratings, seeking continuous improvement in related scores. The ESG Division also manages the ISO Management Systems under the related provisions of equivalent policies and the Operational Impact Strategy. The ESG Division collects, calculates and reviews data related to the operational impact, in line with the associated certified management systems, while it also ensures implementation of corresponding initiatives (e.g. operational net zero transition, energy self-production, energy and emissions monitoring, green building certifications, recycling and circular economy management).
Business Units
The Business Units, namely, Corporate and Investment Banking and Retail Banking, are primarily involved in executing all portfolio-related ESG activities, including the implementation of the financed impact strategy. Key responsibilities are classified under three main categories:
- ESG Strategy
Executing and monitoring financed and specific operational ESG goals and performance targets.
- Sustainable Financing/Funding and Investments
Identifying sustainable financing opportunities and designing relevant solutions and ESG products.
Performing Sustainable Financing assessment, in line with the Sustainable Finance Framework.
Implementing and monitoring Sustainable Investment and Green Bond Frameworks.
- ESG and Climate Risk Management
Performing the ESG Risk Assessment.
Identifying and implementing mitigation action plans for ESG and Climate related risks.
To effectively manage ESG and sustainable financing related activities, a dedicated function, the Sustainability Center of Excellence is being initiated in 2023. In the meantime, CIB ESG coordinator is responsible to oversee ESG and sustainable financing activities. Regarding the Retail Banking Division, the Bank has introduced two ESG coordinators, who are responsible for organising and supporting ESG-related activities.
Group Climate Risk Division (GCRD)
The GCRD has the overall responsibility for overseeing, monitoring and managing CR&E risks. Specifically, the GCRD operates as the Project office responsible for the implementation of the climate related and environmental risks roadmap (“Programme Field”), with a coordinating and supervisory role on all related project streams to ensure alignment with the Bank’s business strategy and the regulatory authorities’ expectations. In this context, the GCRD ensures the implementation of corresponding environmental and sustainability initiatives (frameworks, policies, procedures and products) and compliance with relevant existing and upcoming regulations, under an ongoing bank-wide programme, in line with the agreed supervisory roadmap, which is accelerated where possible. The GCRD is also responsible for coordinating with Business and Risk Units, preparing and submitting for approval the Financed Impact Strategy, and monitoring its implementation. Furthermore, the GCRD leads the 2nd line of defence independent sustainable lending re-assessment process. Specifically, in the context of implementing the approved SFF, the Division is responsible for assessing the sustainability features of new loans and products according to the criteria set within the SFF. Going forward, the role of the GCRD will be expanded, covering the management of ESG risks.
Group Compliance General Division
The Group Compliance General Division monitors compliance with ESG/climate-related regulations and standards. Its key roles include:
Regulatory compliance
- Monitors the regulatory environment and emerging trends around sustainable financing, informs the 1st and 2nd lines of defence and may propose required changes/enhancements for the relevant policies and documents regarding sustainable financing offerings.
- Issues a regulatory bulletin which refers to regulatory developments and their impact on the Bank’s operation in terms of ESG risks.
- Complements the risk management framework and monitors the alignment of institutions’ activities with applicable laws, rules, regulations and standards, including ESG regulatory aspects.
Compliance Risk Assessment
- Assesses conduct risk in relation to ESG.
- Performs compliance checks with regard to ESG-related conduct risk.
Policy Updates
- Maintains the Bank’s conduct related policies (e.g. AML and Sanctions, Anti-Bribery and Corruption, etc.), including their ESG elements.
Product offering monitoring
Via its participation in the Products and Services Committee and process, provides advice and checks on Bank’s ESG product offerings, including that promotional statements do not misrepresent products or services to customers.
Group Operational Risk Sector (GORS)
The GORS is responsible for establishing an effective operational risk management framework and for overseeing its implementation across the Group and across all lines of defence, aligned with regulations, standards, good practices, Internal Policies, Internal Governance Control Manual (IGCM) and with Group’s business objectives and values.
In order to further strengthen the existing Operational Risk Framework in alignment with increased regulatory expectations, as defined in relevant EBA Guidelines and BCBS Principles, the BoD has identified that the management of Non-Financial Risks (NFRs) has become increasingly critical for the Group and decided to address them holistically. Non-Financial Risks include operational risks as well as aspects of ESG risks, strategic risk and reputational risk, and are gradually becoming integrated to the Non-Financial Risks Framework.
In this context, Operational risk arising from ESG factors is being managed in accordance with the requirements set out in the Non-Financial Risk Management Policy and other relevant operational risk management policies.
Internal Audit Group (IAG)
In recent years, the IAG has recognised ESG internal controls and the risk management framework as an area of focus, and has taken several initiatives and actions within its strategy. These aim to ensure adequate coverage of the area, in line with the Bank’s strategy as well as industry and regulatory developments.
- Methodology / Infrastructure – The management of ESG risks and the Bank’s initiatives are recognised as a separate auditable area, subject to risk-assessment. Furthermore, climate risk was recently recognised as a separate risk category assessed in all relevant areas of the audit universe, in line with the Bank’s risk taxonomy. This category will be extended to cover the whole spectrum of ESG risks in line with respective developments in the Bank’s risk definitions. The Bank’s climate risk definition currently covers both physical and transition risk drivers of the C&E risk. The IAG is in the process of operationalising the change and reflect it in the IAG’s risk assessment, audit planning and audit reports, with the aim to monitor the IAG’s coverage in terms of timing and findings, assisting in appropriate future planning and monitoring in this area, including more focused monitoring of relevant issues by the Bank’s Board and the AC. Due to timing considerations, the assessment of the C&E risk per AU line will be reflected in the 2023 risk assessment which informs the 2024 AP.
- Resources – The IAG conforms with the standards of the Institute of Internal Auditors (IIA) International Professional Practices Framework (IPPF), ensuring among others the “appropriateness and sufficiency” of IAG Resources. “Appropriateness and sufficiency” of resources engaged in all audit assignments is key for the IAG. Appropriateness refers to the right mix of knowledge, skills, and other competencies, and sufficiency refers to the quantity of resources needed to accomplish the IAG role with due professional care. Traditionally, the majority of IAG staff possess professional qualifications/certifications from internationally recognised professional bodies, such as ICAEW, ACCA, CIA and CISA. The IAG has extended its pool of professional qualifications/certificates to the area of ESG, with one staff member certified in Sustainability and Climate Risk, and with more auditors to commence relevant certifications from 2023 onwards. The IAG intends to experiment with the available industry professional body offers, such as GARP’s Sustainability and Climate Risk (SCR®) Certificate, CFA’s Certificate in ESG Investing, ICAEW Sustainability Certificate, etc. This comes in parallel with other initiatives aimed at upskilling through dedicated training sessions (e.g. Bank internal, Moody’s, webinars), “on-the-job” upskilling (participation and consultation in the Bank’s projects and initiatives around ESG) and increased awareness (e.g. establishment of IAG’s ESG Focus Group, sharing knowledge on ESG practice and regulatory initiatives, targeted presentation to AC members). At this stage, the IAG has opted to embed the right mix of skills and knowledge within its existing organisational structure, given the multifaceted nature of ESG risks, affecting all businesses and operations of the Bank, to a siloed approach, aiming at a holistic consideration of the Bank’s ESG risks. This approach will be revisited in the future.
- ESG / Audit Universe Coverage and Audit Planning – Following the infrastructure steps described above, since 2021 the IAG has carried out several assignments around ESG, in parallel with the monitoring of the Bank’s initiatives in this area. Specifically, the 2021 annual audit plan (AAP) included participation in the Bank’s ESG Programme Field, and a consulting assignment on ESG reporting. The 2022 AAP included a consulting assignment on the Climate Risk Stress Test 2022 and the commencement of audit assurance work around the operationalization of the C&E Risk Management Framework within targeted areas of the Bank (e.g. Transformation Project; Investments). A similar approach has been planned for the 2023 AAP, with a focus on ESG matters in targeted reviews, taking into account the ECB’s 2022 report on “Good practices for C&E risk management” (e.g. Risk Management and Governance), complemented by a consulting assignment around the Pillar 3 ESG Disclosures. Finally, the IAG has considered the supervisory requirements and specifically the ECB’s report on “Good practices for C&E risk management”, to develop its three-year audit plan around ESG risk, which will be completed within the 2023 risk assessment and audit planning exercise, to be approved by the AC by year-end (indicative areas of focus are governance, regulatory compliance, risk management and disclosures). Key areas of focus include risk materiality, governance and strategy, C&E risk management framework, products design and offering, disclosures, etc. These initiatives come in addition to the existing coverage by IA in ESG-related areas, such as consideration of AML-perspectives in loan origination (governance-social financing practices), review of compliance with code of conduct or market practice codes (governance operational and financing practices) and relevant non-recurring and forensic audit work. The outcome of IAG assignments is reflected in the audit reports, which are distributed to Management, the AC and the external auditors. The IAG meets frequently with Senior Management to discuss audit findings and the progress made in resolving them. It also prepares quarterly reports for the Audit Committee.
The IAG is also dedicated to integrating ESG friendly practices into its operations, by increasing staff awareness, taking actions to reduce its environmental footprint and positively impact the environment and contribute to society (e.g. charity work and/or contributions), in parallel with the implementation of good governance and human capital management practices. In summary, the IAG places significant focus to ensure that adequate coverage is provided in the field of ESG risks, as well as that its operations integrate ESG aligned and impact practices. Overall, the IAG is committed towards the mindset shift that ESG requires. It recognises the crucial role of ESG factors in business operations and decision-making, aiming at a proactive and gradual integration of an ESG mindset into audit processes. The aim is to drive positive impact and promote sustainable practices.
Alignment of the Remuneration Policy with the Bank’s environmental and social objectives
The Bank promotes the integration of sustainability factors into its remuneration policies. The Bank’s Remuneration Policy, which applies to all Bank employees and covers their total remuneration, forms an integral part of its corporate governance practice. It promotes sound and effective risk management and is consistent with the objectives of the Bank’s business and risk strategy, corporate culture and values, risk culture, including ESG factors, as well as the long-term interests of the Bank, and should not encourage excessive risk-taking on behalf of the Bank.
The Bank aims to integrate climate and environmental risk aspects into its Remuneration Policy. In particular, within 2023, the Remuneration Policy will be linked to specific climate risk performance indicators/KPIs to monitor progress towards achieving the Bank’s targets in terms of climate risk management, financed and operational impact.
Dedicated group-wide programme to address the requirements of the ESG ecosystem
The Group launched an initiative, namely “Programme Field”, with an aim to develop and implement its sustainability strategy, integrate climate risks, fulfil its UNEP FI PRB signatory commitments and ensure readiness to comply with upcoming sustainability-related regulations (i.e. EU Green Deal, ECB Guide on climate-related and environmental risks, EU Taxonomy Regulation, etc.). Through this initiative, the Group has also identified, assessed and implements climate-related and environmental (CR&E) risk action plans within the three lines of defence.
Integration of ESG Risk Management across the three lines of defence
The ESG Risk Governance involves various key stakeholders (i.e., business functions, Units, and Committees). The Group applies a model of defined roles and responsibilities regarding the management of ESG risks across the 3 lines of defence, considering all relevant guidelines and regulatory requirements:
- 1st line of defence
The business units (CIB and Retail Banking) are responsible for assessing, managing and monitoring their risk levels in all risk categories, including ESG risks. The CIB ESG coordinator, along with the Retail Banking Division ESG coordinators, are responsible for undertaking all relevant ESG and sustainable finance activities. In addition, the role of the ESG Division in the 1st line of defence has been revisited to include the responsibility for the Operational Impact Strategy as well as Sustainability Reporting, Environmental & Energy Reporting (EMAS Report, Greenhouse Gases Emissions Report per ISO14064) and ESG ratings.
- 2nd line of defence
The Group Risk Management General Division (GRMGD) is independent from the business units and has full responsibility in setting the risk strategy and risk appetite framework, including ESG risks. Within the GRMGD, the dedicated Group Climate Risk Division has been established, with the overall responsibility for overseeing, monitoring, and managing ESG risks and sustainable financing activities, in cooperation with the other GRMGD sectors/divisions, as well as with Group Compliance General Division.
- 3rd line of defence
The Internal Audit Group (IAG) independently reviews the adequacy and effectiveness of the internal control framework in place regarding ESG risk management, following a risk-based approach.
Sustainable Finance Framework Assessment Tool
Eurobank has developed a web-based tool automating the process for assessing and reviewing financings against the criteria and alignment levels of the Sustainable Finance Framework (SFF). The tool is currently used for the Corporate Portfolio, and underpins the classification, evaluation and approval of sustainable financing opportunities in a structural, workflow-based, manner. Moreover, the SFF assessment tool guides its users so they may identify financing opportunities and proactively engage with clients on sustainable financing dialogue.
ESG awareness and capacity building
Eurobank is placing great emphasis on building capacity among its employees, so they are able to support its clients on their sustainability journey and their green transition. To this end, in addition to launching ESG initiatives for its clients, Eurobank implements an ESG upskilling plan for its employees. Eurobank’s internal awareness sessions regarding ESG and CR&E matters cover both members of the management body and other stakeholders across the Bank (e.g. business units). Additionally, the Bank has offered training to stakeholders from all three lines of defence (i.e. business units, risk management units, Internal Audit) regarding the SFF, to enhance their understanding. Specifically, the following awareness initiatives took place within 2022:
Employee ESG awareness training modules
Within 2022, the Bank launched “ESG Thinking”, an ESG awareness programme for employees, consisting of the following modules:
- Module 1 – ESG and World
Fundamentals of ESG, megatrends and related risk and opportunities as well as the importance of ESG within an organisation described through business cases.
- Module 2 – ESG and the Bank
Key drivers of ESG, its impact on the banking industry and the ESG regulatory landscape. The ways in which the Bank engages with ESG through frameworks, initiatives and products.
- Module 3 – ESG and Me
Content aiming to cultivate an open and growth mindset when dealing with ESG issues by motivating employees to take personal action through practical steps personally and professionally.
In 2022, 2,543 employees participated in the ESG Thinking programme, totalling 3,132 learning hours.
Dedicated training sessions to Business Units
Apart from the general upskilling programmes, within 2022-2023 the Bank conducted dedicated sessions tailored to the requirements of specific business units and functions, crucial for delivering the Bank’s strategy. These sessions focused on the following topics:
- ESG ecosystem, Sustainable Finance Framework (SFF) and assessment tool:
Introduction to the ESG ecosystem, the role of the financial sector in driving action for sustainable development and the relevant regulatory framework.
Presentation of the approaches and eligible activities of the SFF and its integration into the loan granting process.
Presentation of the workflow and functionalities of the SFF assessment tool along with practical application on case studies.
- Use of sustainability reporting for identifying sustainable financing opportunities:
Introduction to sustainability reporting and major reporting frameworks and standards. Demonstration of the link between the Bank’s SFF and information in sustainability reports. Case studies identifying key sustainability report elements and their link to sustainable financing opportunities
During 2022-2023, there were over 500 employee participations in the dedicated training sessions for the Bank’s business units, totalling over 1,300 hours of training.